Payroll is more than simply transferring money to employees. It also involves tax deductions, government remittances, statutory obligations, and compliance with provincial labour laws. In Canada, payroll can be structured in different ways depending on how employees are paid.

Broadly, there are three main types of payroll, each defining how pay is calculated and applied:

1. Hourly payroll
2. Salary payroll
3. Commission-based or contract payroll

Each payroll type serves a different business model and employee role. Understanding the differences helps businesses manage payments correctly while staying compliant with CRA regulations.

1. Hourly Payroll

Hourly payroll compensates employees based on the number of hours worked.

How employees are paid:

• Employee clocks hours
• Pay is calculated: hours × hourly rate
• Overtime rules apply
• Breaks and statutory requirements must be observed

Typical use cases:

• Retail workers
• Hospitality/service staff
• Trades and labour roles
• Warehouse operators
• Part-time shifts

Important compliance notes in Canada:

Hourly payroll must comply with:

• Provincial minimum wage
• Overtime rules (typically 1.5×)
• Paid statutory holidays
• Vacation pay accumulation

Pros:

• Flexible staffing costs
• Accurate tracking of labour time
• Useful for variable workloads

Cons:

• Requires time tracking systems
• Payroll calculations are more complex
• Overtime increases labour cost

Hourly payroll is ideal for businesses with fluctuating demand or changing employee schedules.

2. Salary Payroll

Salary payroll pays employees a fixed amount on a recurring schedule (weekly, bi-weekly, semi-monthly, or monthly), regardless of hours worked.

How payment works:

• Employee receives set annual salary
• Divided over pay periods
• Hours worked do not change pay (except under special rules)

Typical use cases:

• Managers
• Admin and office roles
• Marketing & finance positions
• Software developers
• Corporate professionals

Key compliance points in Canada:

Salaried employees may be:

• Eligible for overtime
• OR exempt based on role and classification (Overtime rules vary provincially some salaried jobs are exempt; others are not.)

Pros:

• Simple payroll forecasting
• Stable employee costs
• Attractive for professional roles

Cons:

• Less flexible
• Harder to scale down costs during slow periods

Salary payroll is best suited for roles with stable responsibilities and consistent workloads.

3. Commission-Based or Contract Payroll

This payroll type pays workers based on performance, sales, or contract terms rather than time worked.

Examples:

• Sales commission (percentage of revenue)
• Project-based payment
• Freelance invoicing
• Contractor fee
• Piece-rate pay

Typical use cases:

• Real estate agents
• Freelance designers
• Sales reps
• Insurance agents
• Consultants
• Independent contractors

Tax implications:

Commission-based workers may be:

• Employees receiving T4s (with deductions) OR
• Independent contractors receiving T4A or invoices (Employment classification matters significantly.)

Pros:

• Pay tied to results and productivity
• Low fixed cost for employer
• Motivational compensation

Cons:

• Income unpredictability for worker
• Potential legal complications if misclassified
• Contractors are not entitled to EI or CPP employer contributions

Commission-based payroll is ideal for revenue-driven roles where output is measurable.

How to Choose the Right Payroll Type

Business Goal	Recommended Payroll Type
Budget flexibility	Hourly payroll
Predictable monthly costs	Salary payroll
Reward high performance	Commission payroll
Short-term or project hires	Contract/commission
Professional or managerial roles	Salary payroll
Seasonal workload	Hourly payroll

Often, companies use a combination.

Example:

• Managers on salary
• Staff on hourly
• Salespeople on commission

How Ingenious Professional Consultants Helps Canadian Businesses

At Ingenious Professional Consultants, we support:

• Hourly payroll setup
• Salary-based payroll
• Commission & contractor payroll
• T4/T4A issuance
• CPP/EI/tax deductions
• Vacation & stat holiday calculations
• ROE issuance
• Provincial compliance review

We make sure payroll is handled accurately and legally regardless of type.

Conclusion

The three types of payroll hourly, salary, and commission/contract each support different workforce needs and compensation structures. Choosing the right model helps ensure fairness, compliance, and efficiency in business operations.

Whether managing a small retail team or a growing professional workforce, understanding payroll structures empowers business owners to pay employees properly and confidently.

FAQ